Authentic Greek Salad Recipe (Horiatiki, No Lettuce)

Horiatiki means village salad, and the name is a clue to what it is: whatever was growing outside, cut up and dressed with oil. It is not a composed dish and it does not want a technique. What it wants is four or five ingredients that are actually good, which is a much harder requirement than a long method.

Two things separate it from the thing served as Greek salad in most of the world. There is no lettuce, and the feta arrives as a single thick slab laid across the top, not crumbled through. The slab matters more than it sounds: it keeps the cheese from disintegrating into the oil, and you break pieces off it as you eat.

The dressing is not a dressing. It is olive oil, a little red wine vinegar, salt and dried oregano, added directly to the bowl. Nothing is emulsified and nothing is whisked.

Key preparation steps

1. Cut tomatoes into thick wedges and salt them first, on their own.
2. Add cucumber, green pepper, red onion and olives.
3. Lay a whole slab of feta across the top, do not crumble it.
4. Pour over good olive oil, a splash of vinegar, and a heavy pinch of dried oregano.

Why is there no lettuce in a real Greek salad?

Because horiatiki is a summer salad from a hot country, and lettuce does not grow well in a Greek August. The salad is built from what thrives in that heat: tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers and onions.

There is a separate and entirely legitimate Greek salad called maroulosalata that is made of shredded cos lettuce with spring onion and dill, and it is eaten mostly in spring. It is simply a different dish. If a menu in Greece says horiatiki, no lettuce is coming.

Why the feta must be a slab, not crumbled

Crumbled feta breaks down into the oil at the bottom of the bowl and turns the whole thing into a paste within minutes. A slab, cut about a centimetre and a half thick and laid across the top, stays intact.

It also changes how the salad is eaten. You take a piece of feta with a piece of tomato, rather than getting cheese distributed evenly through everything. Sprinkle the oregano onto the feta itself and pour a little oil over it directly.

Buy feta in brine, in a block, made from sheep's milk. Pre-crumbled feta in a tub is usually cow's milk, drier and considerably less good. Real feta is a protected designation product and the packet will say so.

Salt the tomatoes first

This is the one piece of actual technique in the recipe. Cut the tomatoes into thick wedges, put them in the bowl alone, and salt them. Leave them for five minutes while you cut everything else.

The salt pulls juice out of the tomatoes, and that juice combines with the olive oil to make the only sauce the salad gets. This is the liquid that everyone fights over with bread at the end of the meal, and Greeks have a word for that specific act of bread-dipping: papara. Salting at the end instead means the tomatoes stay dry and the oil stays separate.

Which olive oil, and how much?

More than you think, and it should be a good extra virgin one that you would be happy to taste on bread. There is nowhere for a poor oil to hide here. Greek oils from Kalamata or Crete are the obvious choice and are usually grassy and slightly peppery.

Four tablespoons for a salad serving four is a reasonable amount, and the bottom of the bowl should be visibly oily when you have finished. Vinegar is optional and should be restrained, around a teaspoon, since the tomatoes and the brine from the feta are already bringing acidity.

Capers, purslane and other regional additions

On Santorini you will often get capers or caper leaves. On Crete, barley rusk goes underneath to soak up the juices, at which point the dish becomes dakos. In parts of the mainland, purslane appears in summer.

All of these are legitimate. What tends not to appear is lettuce, balsamic vinegar, anything creamy, or a pre-made dressing from a bottle.

Tips from my kitchen